-
HTE
Lawsuits,
against Imitation 'Chi
Machines'.
The Chi Machine
® is a patented
name, and
product. There are multiple imitations that use the
name 'The Chi Machine'
which is illegal. There is only one original Chi
Machine ®, the Sun Ancon,
distributed by HTE, created by acclaimed
Japaneses scientist, Dr. Inoue.

The Original Sun Ancon
Chi Machine ® creator
and his exclusive distributor,
Dr. Shizuo Inoue and Hsin
Ten Enterprise Chairman
Gordon Pan.
HTE SETTLES ITS LAWSUIT AGAINST CELEBRITY
FARMINGDALE, New York, February 23, 2001.
Hsin Ten Enterprise USA, Inc.
("HTE USA") today announced
that it has settled its lawsuit against Celebrity
and its principals,
Blaine Ferguson and Edward J. Sula, Jr. The suit,
commenced by HTE on August
24, 2000 in the United States District Court for the
Eastern District of
New York, alleged that Celebrity, Ferguson, and Sula
infringed U.S. Patent
No. 5,107,822, U.S. Patent No. Des. 329,499, and HTE's
trademark THE CHI
MACHINE ®. Also at issue in the case was HTE's
tortious interference
claim involving Celebrity's alleged practice of
building its sales force
by knowingly recruiting distributors from HTE's sales
network, and using
HTE's confidential and proprietary information to do
so.
Celebrity, Ferguson, and Sula, have
discontinued their sales of Celebrity's
NX-1 machine.
"HTE USA ª
intends to continue to monitor the
marketplace and to take appropriate legal action
to protect its valuable
intellectual property rights and its distributor
network," said Richard
Chuang, President and CEO of Hsin Ten Enterprise
USA, Inc.
HTE USA is a New York based seller of health
related products, including
the patented THE CHI MACHINE ® therapeutic
massager. NY2-1170825.1
HTE USA SETTLES ITS LAWSUIT
AGAINST HOME SHOPPING NETWORK AND ALEXANDRIA
SUGARING
PRODUCTS, FARMINGDALE, New York, April 17, 2001.
Hsin Ten Enterprise USA, Inc. ("HTE
USA") today announced
that it has settled its lawsuit against Home
Shopping Network, Inc. ("HSN")
and Alexandria Sugaring Products Inc.
("Alexandria"). The suit,
commenced by HTE USA on January 12, 2000 in the United
States District
Court for the Eastern District of New York, alleged
that HSN and Alexandria
infringed U.S. Patent No. 5,107,822 and U.S. Patent
No. Des. 329,499 by
the manufacture and sale of the Oxyciser and Oxyflow
machines.
Under the settlement, both HSN and
Alexandria have discontinued their
manufacture and sale of the Oxyciser and Oxyflow
machines. In addition,
under the settlement, a monetary payment was made
to HTE USA by both defendants.
In addition, a consent judgment was entered by
the Court against Alexandria
in which HTE USA's patents were held to be valid and
infringed by the manufacture
and sale of the Oxyciser and Oxyflow machines.
"HTE USA is pleased
with the settlement and
the Court's judgment and intends to continue to
monitor the market place
and to take appropriate legal action to protect
its valuable intellectual
property rights" said Richard Chuang, President
and CEO of Hsin Ten Enterprise
USA, Inc.
HTE USA is a New York based seller of
health related products,
including the patented THE CHI MACHINE ®
therapeutic massager.
Hsin Ten Enterprise USA Inc. v. Clark
Enterprises, et al.
Mealey Publications
NEW YORK - Jan. 8, 2001
The New York long-arm statute provides
jurisdiction in federal
court in Manhattan over a Kansas company named in a
patent and trademark
infringement action by a New York corporation, a
federal judge ruled Dec.
29 (Hsin Ten Enterprise USA Inc. v. Clark
Enterprises, et al., No.
00-5878 [SAS], S.D. N.Y.).
U.S. Judge Shira A. Scheindlin of the Southern
District of New York
refused to dismiss claims asserted by Hsin Ten
Enterprise USA Inc. against
Clark Enterprises Inc. However, the judge dismissed
claims against Clark
Enterprises proprietor Clifford Clark for lack of
jurisdiction.
Judge Scheindlin based her jurisdictional
findings on the sale of the
allegedly infringing product through a website
operated by Clark and available
to New York residents.
Hsin Ten, a New York
company, has the exclusive
right to manufacture, use and sell aerobic
exercise machines under two
patents owned by Skylite Industry Ltd. Hsin Ten
also sells an "electric
massage apparatus" under the mark "The Chi
Machine"; Hsin Ten owns the
mark.
Clark Enterprises, a Kansas company owned
by Clifford Clark, began
selling a machine called
"The Chi Exerciser 2000"
in
January 2000. Hsin Ten alleged that the
machine infringes the Skylite
patents and that its name infringes its trademark.
Source: Mealey Publications offers
attorneys case summaries,
news and information in 25 areas of law.
http://www.lexisone.com/news/nlibrary/n010901n.html
On October 17, 2001, Clark Enterprises,
Salina, Kansas, concluded
litigation. The Settlement Agreement resolved
all claims between Clark
Enterprises and HTE. The precise terms of the
Settlement Agreement are
confidential.
As part of the Settlement Agreement, Clark
Enterprises is permitted to sell its passive
aerobic exerciser, The Exerciser
2000 ª Model CME2K. For those
interested in the exact final
outcome of this litigation, contact the United
States District Court for
the Southern District of New York to request a copy
of such.
Further References:
Hsin Ten Enterprise USA Inc. v. Clark
Enterprises
http://www.nysba.info/committees/cplr/recent.html
Hsin Ten v. Clark
http://www.mealeys.com/TEC0201.html
Hsin Ten Enterprises United States v. Clark
Enterprises & Clifford
D. Clark
http://eon.law.harvard.edu/ilaw/Jurisdiction/Hsin_Ten_Sum.html
Intellectual Property In Cyberspace
http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/ilaw/Jurisdiction/Hsin_Ten_Sum.html
http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/ilaw/Jurisdiction/Hsin_Ten_Full.html
- December 28, 2000 - 00 CIV. 5878 (SAS) - Shira A.
Scheindlin
For The Record:
Lawsuits between rival products are unfortunately
common place in American
society. This information has been provided due to
public interest and
is not meant to be intentionally derogatory or make
any negative statement
regarding the quality and standards of the above
mentioned companies and
their products. Consumers
are advised to research
products in depth and draw conclusions for
themselves.
-
|